I finished Emotional Geology last night. I was a bit sceptical at first, it's not the type of thing I normally read, and there was something about the writing style that annoyed me, too many commas. However, I did end up enjoying it, it was very well written, (apart from the style thing) and quite lyrical. It captured the scenery beautifully and made me want to go and visit the Outer Hebrides. One small thing, I think it could have finished a bit sooner. The last chapter felt like a long epilogue, when really the story was wrapped up by that point. Still, I look forward to reading Star Gazing, which I have heard, is even better.