grabit Posted September 9, 2008 Share Posted September 9, 2008 i'm more the sort that thinks both should be considered separately.. altho i do try to read a book before seeing the movie when i can, as i can imagine the characters and settings without having the movie dictate that to me.. altho, of course, i can never even look at a Harry Potter book without seeing the movie characters now.. same with Northen Lights (Golden Compass) and even my old Anne of Green Gables books have suffered the same fate. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Stephanie2008 Posted September 11, 2008 Share Posted September 11, 2008 PS I Love You. I read the book first and was totally disappointed with the movie. I think it was because I loved the book and the film wouldn't measure up no matter what. I'm really looking forward to the Confessions of a Shopaholic film. I hope it is as good as the books because they could have some sequels on their hands. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest ii Posted September 11, 2008 Share Posted September 11, 2008 I was just thinking that at least the Shopaholic movie can't be as boring as the books! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Stephanie2008 Posted September 11, 2008 Share Posted September 11, 2008 I was just thinking that at least the Shopaholic movie can't be as boring as the books! I like the books - but then I'm easy pleased Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest ii Posted September 11, 2008 Share Posted September 11, 2008 I didn't mind the first one, it was okay. But the rest are just the same! She doesn't grow one bit. It's really annoying. It's the same store, all over again, in slightly different clothes. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Janet Posted September 12, 2008 Share Posted September 12, 2008 They've set the Shopaholic film in the US, haven't they? She wasn't even there in the first book, was she?! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kenny Posted September 13, 2008 Share Posted September 13, 2008 Eragon Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Severnlad Posted September 13, 2008 Share Posted September 13, 2008 War of the Worlds Have seen both films and neither of them were true representations of the book. The last one by Stephen Spielberg was a good film but unfortunately it was set in America. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Inver Posted September 13, 2008 Share Posted September 13, 2008 The various Harry Potters Chocolat Girl with a Pearl Earring The Shell Seekers (done on TV & as a play) Cammomile Lawn (done on TV) The Joy Luck Club Memoirs of a Geisha Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Roadrunner Posted September 17, 2008 Share Posted September 17, 2008 I'm guessing most people did this with Lord of the Rings? I haven't met anyone yet who watched one of the films then read the book. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Michelle Posted September 17, 2008 Share Posted September 17, 2008 I'm guessing most people did this with Lord of the Rings? I haven't met anyone yet who watched one of the films then read the book. I did... I read the whole of the first book, then half the second.. then gave up! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kylie Posted September 17, 2008 Share Posted September 17, 2008 I read each Lord of the Rings book just before the movie came out. Actually I think I read the 2nd and 3rd books before the 2nd movie came out, which I think was just as well, because the 2nd movie didn't leave off where the 2nd book did (? something like that). Related to this topic: I was watching a newish episode of The Simpsons last night and they a rip-off of the Harry Potter phenomenon which had the family lining up for the last book's release and dressed up as characters from the books. Comic Book Guy turns to Lisa and patronisingly points out discrepancies between her outfit and the character's ('the griffin should be facing the other way' etc). Lisa points out that she based her outfit on the book, not the movie. Everyone starts laughing and Comic Book Guy leaves the line in disgrace. I thought that was terrific! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
nursenblack Posted September 18, 2008 Share Posted September 18, 2008 Right now the only one that comes to mind is Nicholas Sparks' The Notebook. I watched the movie several months before reading it and thought it was much more entertaining than the novel, which is usually not the case with me. I prefer to read a novel first because I don't want to be influenced too much by a film. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
scottishbookworm Posted September 19, 2008 Share Posted September 19, 2008 I've read the book "Atonement" and seen the movie of the same name, I thought the movie was better Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jo-Bridge Posted September 20, 2008 Share Posted September 20, 2008 The Godfather and Silence of the lambs were great films ...and I thought awful books! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
scottishbookworm Posted September 20, 2008 Share Posted September 20, 2008 Right now the only one that comes to mind is Nicholas Sparks' The Notebook. I watched the movie several months before reading it and thought it was much more entertaining than the novel, which is usually not the case with me. I prefer to read a novel first because I don't want to be influenced too much by a film.Not seen the "Notebook" or read the book Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Stephanie2008 Posted September 26, 2008 Share Posted September 26, 2008 I have seen the Notebook, the film, but have not read the book. I loved the film, it was so sweet. I cried quite a bit at the end Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bev Posted September 26, 2008 Share Posted September 26, 2008 Just ordered The Notebook ( Book and DVD ) for my daughter, so I will have to read/watch of course, I've heard they are a bit of a weepy, so will watch/read when alone otherwise the kids take the p**s when I start to blub !!! I read Attonment before I saw the film and found the film better than the book ( which is rare !!) Memoirs of a Geisha, I thought the book was much better than the film. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kylie Posted September 27, 2008 Share Posted September 27, 2008 Good idea, Bev. I always wait till I'm alone to watch it because I cry quite a lot I haven't read the book yet though. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ceinwenn Posted September 27, 2008 Author Share Posted September 27, 2008 The Notebook is one of the few movies I have seen that made me cry! Great movie, but haven't read the book - yet! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bookwormmum Posted September 27, 2008 Share Posted September 27, 2008 I felt the same about Nicholas Sparks' A Walk to Remember. I read the book on the strength of the film, but the book lacked the emotional impact that the film had. On the same note, I also read the book based on Housewife 45 drama, and found it didn't keep my interest as much, but then again the Lady who wrote it never believe that it would be published to the thousands. I preferred the ending for Neil Gaiman's Stardust, but enjoyed the film so much more. It just seemed even more magical in film. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Raven Posted October 6, 2008 Share Posted October 6, 2008 War of the Worlds Have seen both films and neither of them were true representations of the book. The last one by Stephen Spielberg was a good film but unfortunately it was set in America. As much as I love the 1950's version - I do like a good 'B' Movie - I would pay real money (instead of the Monopoly cash I usually use) to see a decent period adaptation of War of the Worlds. Lord of the Rings has to rank high on my list as a decent stab at a book-to-film transfer, but the one novel I would put at the top of my list Starter For Ten, by David Nicholls. Trying not to spoil it for anyone who hasn't read or seen it, after an excellent build up the end of the book was a real let-down for me, as I felt the main character simply ran from his responsibilities. In the screenplay, which, interestingly was also written by Nicholls, I felt he corrected this mistake and gave the story a much more satisfying conclusion. In short, watch the film, skip the book! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kylie Posted October 7, 2008 Share Posted October 7, 2008 Well, I'll proudly admit to liking both War of the Worlds adaptations (and I love the book as well). I didn't love the sappy Hollywood ending of the remake, or the fact that it was set in America, but I could get past that and enjoy it for what it was. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kell Posted October 7, 2008 Share Posted October 7, 2008 As much as I love the 1950's version - I do like a good 'B' Movie - I would pay real money (instead of the Monopoly cash I usually use) to see a decent period adaptation of War of the Worlds. So would I - it's such an epic, sweeping tale and it really doesn't need any changes made to it. They should just make it as is and it would be fantastic! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
scottishbookworm Posted October 7, 2008 Share Posted October 7, 2008 Da vinci code. The movie was at least over in an hour and a half. the movie was better than the book as the book was hard to get into Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.