Q&A by Vikas Swarup
This review contains minor spoilers for the film Slumdog Millionaire
Synopsis (from Amazon)
Former tiffinboy Ram Mohammad Thomas has just got twelve questions correct on a TV quiz-show to win a cool one billion rupees. But he is brutally slung in prison on suspicion of cheating. Because how can a kid from the slums know who Shakespeare was, unless he is pulling a fast one. In the order of the questions on the show, Ram tells us which amazing adventures in his street-kid life gave him the answers. From orphanages to brothels, gangsters to beggar-masters, and into the homes of Bollywood's rich and famous, Ram's story is brimming with the chaotic comedy, heart-stopping tragedy and tear-inducing joyousness of modern India.
Review
I'd seen the film of this before reading the book. I was a little concerned because I tend not to enjoy books when I've seen the film first (and vis versa), it didn't matter with this one though because they were quite a bit different, pretty much only the basis premise were the same. None of the stories were the same (although one was almost the same) but there were some similarities.
in a way I thought the film was better in this way as it meant all the little stories were linked together. In the book you could well have read each story as a seperate story. This made it a bit easier to put down than other books, which is both a good thing and a bad thing! It made it easier to stop if I needed to, but it also meant I was less compelled to pick the book up again when I had finished a chapeter.
this I thought the book did better, in the film it was just a comedy story, in the book it was a little amusing but it had more substance too.
I did find one of the stories in the book kind of boring, and found I read slower at this point.
and I found it dragged a bit. In fact I did find myself generally getting more bored towards the end, I think this may have been because everything was like a little story and I like to vary my reading a bit, it kind of felt like I was reading lots of the same stories all after the other. But by the end I had warmed up to it a bit more.
This was a lovely book which, despite its imperfections, I wouold recommend. There is a bit of everything in this story, and it really paints a picture of life in quite a believeable way. I did find all the coincidences a bit unbelieveable though.
I would probably say I prefered the film, just because it flowed a little better, but it's a close thing, and really it is difficult to compare them as they are very different.
8/10
I'm now reading A Partisan's Daughter by Louis de Bernieres