16. BLUE DIARY - ALICE HOFFMAN (16.04.09 - 18.04.09)
When Ethan Ford fails to show up for work on a brilliant summer morning, none of his neighbours would guess that for more than thirteen years he has been running from his past. His true nature has been locked away, as hidden as his real identity. But sometimes locks spring open, and the devastating truths of Ethan's history shatter the small-town peace of Monroe, affecting family and friends alike.
Now, the police are at the door. Ethan Ford's life as an irreproachable family man and heroic volunteer fireman has come to an end - and Jorie Ford's life is coming apart. Some of the residents at Monroe are rallying behind Ethan. But others, including his wife and son, are wondering what remains true when so much is shown to be false - and how capable we really are of change.
The book introduces the reader to Ethan and Jorie Ford - a couple married for thirteen years who appear to have the perfect life, spending a summer morning together. Until a knock at the door changes everything. This book officially had me torn; at times I was cursing and complaining in frustration and yet I was totally drawn to it and reading it at every available opportunity.
Blue Diary had me curious and wondering from page one. As the blurb suggests, what has been discovered about Ethan Ford causes a ripple effect throughout the small town, including many characters into the story. The effect of what is revealed is presented to the reader through several key characters who are all linked to each other as a result of the uncovered truth. Most of these separate story lines had me hooked but a few side plots felt totally unnecessary and only slowed the novel down.
What is evident from page one is that Hoffman loves to describe the environment, including flowers and insects, in far too much depth. She provides the reader with an exact weather report to set every single scene; for the minority this is great visual imagery but most of the time, it hinders the story too much and becomes incredibly tedious. This was a major flaw of the book, as I cared little about the bees and flowers and wanted the focus more on the characters! The symbolism of the changing weather as the story progresses is impossible to ignore because Hoffman makes it so glaringly obvious.
The ending of Blue Diary left me feeling unsatisfied as several key questions were left unanswered, and this detracted from my overall enjoyment by a significant amount. The plot had an immense amount of potential but Hoffman failed to fill that; despite being a very readable novel and relatively enjoyable, my lasting impression was more negative than positive. Being a huge page turner is not enough to sustain this type of story; it lacked necessary depth and although many perspectives was important, Hoffman merely scratched the surface with a few of these. Regardless of the obvious flaws, I would recommend reading this as the plot is fascinating, even if Hoffman doesn’t give the reader what is expected and needed.
6.5/10