Jump to content

Madeleine

Advanced Member
  • Posts

    4,560
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Madeleine

  1. I agree with you Augury re The Essex Serpent - it was totally hyped and yes it's good and very enjoyable, but.... Waterstone's had it as their book of the year in 2016, but personally I think the Miniaturist, which was their book of the year in 2015, was much better, and deserved the title more.

     

    I did like the characters of Cora and William, but felt some storylines were a bit superfluous, eg Martha's campaigning in London, which didn't really seem to go anywhere.  I did think it was well-written and very atmospheric, with a vivid setting (and some great weather) but I would have preferred it if it had stayed in Essex more.

  2. The Essex Serpent by Sarah Perry - I finished this last night, and whilst I enjoyed it, I don't think it quite lives up to the hype and praise lavished on it (unlike say, The Miniaturist, which I think did live up to it's reputation). It's set in the late 19th Century, with newly widowed Cora Seaborne moving from London to the Essex village of Aldwinter, on the Blackwater estuary which is haunted by the legend of the titular serpent. The "creature" first surfaced, allegedly, a couple of hundred years previously, and now it's rumoured to be back, and the villagers are convinced it's punishment for their sins, and blame every bad thing that happens eg a crop failure, a dead sheep, a drowning (even though the victim was known to be a heavy drinker) on the serpent. When Cora arrives, accompanied by her strange son Francis (who by today's definition is probably on the autistic/Asperger's spectrum) and maid/companion Martha, people expect a middle-aged, frumpy widow, and instead get a vivacious young woman (who's been freed from a violent, domineering husband) who wanders around the estuary wearing men's trousers and coats, and collecting fossils. She meets the local vicar, William Ransome, who is trying to fight off the superstitious rumours by keeping his parishioners in check with his sermons, and sparks fly between the two, and Cora also befriends his wife, the ailing Stella, and their 3 children. More strange incidents occur, there's an outbreak of mass hysteria, odd things are seen in the local river, and the villagers become even more paranoid. Meanwhile Cora's attachment to William grows, and she's also lusted after by the doctor who tended her husband. It's very Victorian, with shades of "The Crucible" for it's paranoia, and ticks a lot of the standard Victorian gothic boxes, and although I enjoyed most of it, I felt the ending was a bit weak (thinking about it now, it was probably the only way it could have ended, but still feels a bit flat) and I also felt the scenes in London, especially the sub plot about Martha becoming involved with campaigning for better housing, rents etc for poorer people (nothing has changed since!) felt a bit superfluous and unnecessary. Personally I would have preferred it if it had stayed in Essex, but apart from these quibbles I thought it was a good, but not great, read. 8/10

  3. England (48 counties)

    Bedfordshire

    Berkshire

    Bristol

    Buckinghamshire

    Cambridgeshire

    Cheshire

    City of London

    Cornwall (including Isles of Scilly)

    Cumbria

    Derbyshire

    Devon

    Dorset

    County Durham

    East Sussex

    Essex - The Essex Serpent by Sarah Perry

    Gloucestershire

    Greater London (excluding the City of London

    Greater Manchester

    Hampshire

    Herefordshire

    Hertfordshire

    Isle of Wight

    Kent

    Lancashire

    Leicestershire

    Lincolnshire (including North Lincolnshire. and North East Lincolnshire

    Merseyside

    Norfolk

    North Yorkshire (including Middlesbrough, Redcar and Cleveland, York, and Stockton-on-Tees south of the River Tees) - Some Veil Did Fall by Kirsty Ferry (set mainly in Whitby)

    Northamptonshire

    Northumberland

    Nottinghamshire

    Oxfordshire

    Rutland

    Shropshire

    Somerset - The Trysting Tree by Linda Gillard

    Staffordshire

    Suffolk

    Surrey

    Tyne and Wear

    Warwickshire

    West Midlands

    West Sussex

    East Riding of Yorkshire (including Kingston-upon-Hull)

    South Yorkshire

    West Yorkshire

    Wiltshire

    Worcestershire

     

    Wales (8 counties)

    Clwyd

    Dyfed

    South Glamorgan

    Mid Glamorgan

    West Glamorgan

    Gwent

    Gwynedd

    Powys

     

    Scotland (35 counties)

    Aberdeen

    Aberdeenshire

    Angus

    Argyll and Bute

    Ayrshire and Arran

    Banffshire

    Berwickshire

    Caithness

    Clackmannanshire

    Dumfries

    Dunbartonshire

    Dundee

    East Lothian

    Edinburgh

    Fife

    Glasgow

    Inverness

    Kincardineshire

    Lanarkshire

    Midlothian

    Moray

    Nairn

    Orkney

    Perth and Kinross

    Renfrewshire

    Ross and Cromarty

    Roxburgh, Ettrick and Lauderdale

    Shetland - Cold Earth by Ann Cleeves

    Stirling and Falkirk

    Sutherland

    The Stewartry of Kirkcudbright

    Tweeddale

    West Lothian

    Western Isles

    Wigtown

     

    Northern Ireland

    Antrim

    Armagh

    Down

    Fermanagh

    Londonderry/Derry

    Tyrone

    Edited just now by Madeleine

    Share this post


    Link to post
    Share on other sites
    •  
    •  
    •  
    •  
    •  
    •  
    •  
    •  
    •  

                            

  4. I watched it on Saturday (well most of it) for the first time in ages, I agree it did fall apart at the end a bit, getting soppy.  I agree with your theory about who or what is locked up, and it's no secret that a certain character will return.  Didn't think much of Bill either way to be honest.

  5. All the emoticons.  I'm just on a laptop, worked fine before.  I can get the emoticons, it's just that they don't come up as pictures like they did before the upgrade, so I can't always tell which is which until I select one.  I get a series of very faint black dots, with the emoticon abbreviation such as a colon and a bracket for :) , hope that makes sense.

×
×
  • Create New...