Book # 31: Heretic by Bernard Cornwell
Synopsis:
Heretic begins with a bloody battle outside Calais in 1347, a short time before the city fell to the English. The sympathetic Thomas of Hookton is bending every sinew at the service of his master, the Earl of Northampton; after risking his life time and again, Thomas finds himself commissioned to track down the most sacred relic in Christendom, the Holy Grail. He travels to Gascony, seat of power of his nemesis, Guy Vexille. Utilising his archers, Thomas conducts a fierce guerrilla war against Vexille, and yearns for a face-to-face encounter. But then Thomas is routed and finds his campaign in shreds, facing the twin enemies of the church and the plague.
Thoughts:
This is the third and final book in Cornwell's 'Grail Quest' trilogy. Thomas of Hookton heads south to his family's lands of Astarac in an attempt to find The Grail. Given his own archers and men-at-arms by the Earl of Northampton, he takes control of a castle and starts raiding nearby villages in the hope that he will attract the attention of his cousin, Guy Vexille. Things start to turn sour, though, when he saves a woman accused of heresy from being burned at the stake. His men believe this will bring nothing but ill luck but Thomas has (rather quickly!) fallen in love, much to the jealousy of his friend Robbie.
All in all, this is a reasonable conclusion to the trilogy, but it is somewhat of a let down on the historical side. Cornwell freely admits that only the opening and closing passages are based on real history. I guess that he ultimately had to deal with Thomas's story and his reluctant search for The Grail. The problem I found was that it became a little formulaic and predictable. Thomas falls in love, something bad happens, the odds are stacked against him, he has a seemingly neverending supply of arrows just when he needs it, etc etc.
It's Cornwell's writing that saves it, with that free-flowing, comfortable style of his that makes everything seem natural. I can't help feeling that he'd put himself in a bit of a corner with this story, as he had to answer the questions he'd posed sooner or later, and veering away from the real history makes it feel slightly less authentic. Also, I don't think the characters in this trilogy have ever been as good, or the story as enthralling, as they were in his Arthurian 'Warlord' trilogy.
It's still a good read, though, and I wanted to get to the end and find out if Thomas survived and found The Grail.
7/10