Forgive me for being such a fangirl here, but I'm going to spout off about my feelings on RTD the scriptwriter. Although I agree that RTD didn't write the best episode of Doctor Who ever, I would like to defend him as I think he has written some great ones in the past. However, it is interesting that from what I understand, the scripts I think are his best, are also the ones he apparently had to deliver in very tight timescales and mostly with small budgets. My three favourites are Boom Town from series one, and Tooth and Claw and Love and Monsters from series two. Boom Town was a last minute script which had to be low cost and I thought was an incredibly thought provoking piece on the moral dilemmas facing the Doctor. Tooth and Claw was written in the space of a week when another script had to be dropped, and I think has almost everything I want in a Doctor Who episode - scary monster, comic moments, lots of running and a thrilling plot. Love and Monsters was the first "Doctor-lite" episode due to the last minute inclusion of a Christmas special that year, meaning they had to film 14 episodes in the time allotted for 13. I know it really divides opinion, but I think it is a fantastic moment of reflection on the consequences of coming into contact with our great hero.
And this leaves me with an issue with the series to come this year. I think RTD wrote too many scripts in the series he has been in charge of, and that he had too much control over his own work, leading to these supposed "epic" finales, which I think for the most part, were too big on budget and effects and trying to impress, and not about the story and the characters. The best scripts from all of the new series so far, have come from other writers, who have been limited to one story each (in my opinion, the top two writers have been Steven Moffat and Paul Cornell). So, the probiem I have is that will one of my favourite writers be able to deliver the same level of scripts and stories he's produced in the single stories he's written in previous series, or will he spread himself too thin in his time as head writer? For the first time since the launch of the new series, I have been trying to avoid looking at the news and forums around Doctor Who, as I want to be surprised and (hopefully) delighted when the new series with the new Doctor starts, but this means I have no idea how many scripts Moffat himself is writing, or who the other writers are. I hope that Paul Cornell will be writing a new story and that Moffat sets himself limits better than RTD has done, but I have such high hopes for him, I worry that I'm setting him up for a fall in my own eyes.