The Bonehunters by Steven Erikson
With the release of the final novel in Erikson's 'Tales of the Malazan Book of the Fallen' just over three months away I decided it was time to get back to my re-read of the series so that I'm up to speed when that hefty tome lands on my doormat
On my first read through this was my favourite book in the series. This time through I'm not so sure. There's no doubting that it's a fantastic book but, this time, I found that the first half fell victim to the number of characters and the multiple changes in viewpoint that Erikson has to use as a result. He skips between them like lightning and, on occasion, without much of relevance to say. A bit of judicious editing to tighten up the first 500 pages would have turned this into a masterpiece. Unfortunately, this is a flaw that he carries over into the next book, Reaper's Gale, which is easily my least favourite of the series. Shame. Still, he pulled things back on track after that, so he obviously learned his lesson.
That said, the second half of The Bonehunters is magnificent. Whereas, in each of the first five books, he had dealt with a specific plot on a specific continent, in The Bonehunters Erikson finally begins to bring his grand scheme together, and all the plots (and characters) start to converge. It is a massive juggling act, and the fact that he gets so close to pulling it off to perfection is testament to his grasp of his tale. Once the aftermath of the siege of Y'Ghatan has been dealt with the story truly kicks into top gear, and the resulting climax is both breathless and breathtaking - page-turning stuff of the highest order. Gods meddle, forces clash, set-ups from earlier books finally pay-off, Paran and Apsalar begin to show their true power, and Kalam's relentless running battle with The Claw had my eyes flying across the page. And we finally find out just why people are so terrified of Icarium.
Amidst all the action he still does not forget the characters. It's great to find out more about Shadowthrone and Cotillion; the relationships between Karsa Orlong and Samar Dev, Paran and Apsalar, Mappo and Icarium etc are fleshed out wonderfully. Mappo's grief at his failure, in particular, is heartbreaking. There are also plenty of laugh-out-loud moments. Erikson has a wonderfully dry sense of humour that works really well.
When all's said and done, this book is a little like The Empire Strikes Back. It takes great delight in putting the characters in the worst situations possible, and leaves you wondering how the hell some of them are going to get out alive. And, above all else, it leaves you craving more.
9/10