My favorite book, 9/10 from me.
I read the book first then I saw the movie on TV and I couldn't watch it. I tuned in during the fishing trip scene and it was lacking so much I had to turn it off. That was the only scene I watched, but I am willing to judge the entire movie on it.
I also didn't like that Jack didn't have red hair (giving the impression of Irish decent and adding to his character), and the Indian wasn't as big as it says in the book. Seems like little things, but they are important when you read the book. I'm sure if I watched the whole movie I would have more to complain about, lol.