Set in Stone ~ Linda Newbery

[Inver]

This was my book day swap with Lucybird and it was a great read.

 

It starts in 1920 with an exhibition at a gallery but most of the book is set in 1898 onwards. 'Fourwinds' is the background for this page turner of a book. Main character parts are taken up by Samuel Godwin, the artist employed to tutor two sisters and Charlotte Agnew the governess/companion to the girls. A previous artist tutor sculpted four corners (the Fourwinds) that are mounted on either corner of the imposing house, but one is missing. Why would this be? Will it be found and where? Family secrets and past tragedy unfold and Samuel and Charlotte, independent of each other being to piece things together.

 

The tale unfolds gently at first but then things begin to happen that take you off in a different direction and you wonder how the jigsaw is going to piece together. It is well written and gives the 'atmosphere of a Victorian mystery' and has also been compared to the writing voice of 'Bronte and Austen'.

 

I did enjoy it and would recommend giving this one a read. 8/10

Edited April 27, 2009 by Inver

[Kell]

I've enjoyed this one too - I was lucky enough to review it on publication for a children's books site. I gave it 9/10:

 

"To handle stone is to handle the stuff of life and death, of time and change, the mysteries of the Earth itself..."

 

Fourwinds, a country house close to the South Downs, is the pride of its owner, wealthy widower Ernest Farrow. Samuel Godwin, a gullible young artist employed by Farrow as painter and tutor, is irrevocably drawn into the lives of the three young women at Fourwinds: demure Juliana; Charlotte Agnew, governess and companion, who reveals little of her thoughts and aspirations; and Marianne, the younger daughter, passionate, wilful and unpredictable. Intrigued by Marianne to the point of obsession, Samuel little suspects how thoroughly he is being manipulated.

It's not only the people who fascinate. Samuel is equally entranced by the house itself: Fourwinds; beautifully designed and furnished in Arts and Crafts style, a house to delight and surprise with the attention paid to every detail. What, though, can account for the absence of the West Wind carving, and the disappearance of its creator, the gifted sculptor Gideon Waring, whose name must never be mentioned in Mr. Farrow's hearing? Awed by Waring's skill, Samuel longs to meet him and see more of his work. But in doing so, he uncovers secrets that are both horrifying and dangerous to all.

 

Set in Stone is incredibly intense and deals with some very adult themes (which are dealt with tactfully and sympathetically) therefore it's aimed more at the young adult market rather than younger teens. Very well-written and told from the viewpoint of two characters looking in at the family on the brink of madness that employs them. It's incredibly heady stuff! Love and possession; art and immortality; convention and defiance; ambition and desire:There’s mystery and drama in equal measures which makes for a winning combination, with strong characters, clever plot twists and shocking revelations.

 

Very highly recommended.

[Nollaig]

Ohh lovely,it's nice to read a review of a book I haven't read by her. She also wrote "The Shell House" which I adore, and have yet to get again, and "The Damage Done".

 

Thanks for the reviews guys!