PDA

View Full Version : The Thirteenth Tale - Diane Setterfield


chicken
15th December 2007, 14:27
:confused: I have never written a review before so please bear with me if I ramble!
Synopsis: "Angelfield House stands abandoned and forgotten. It was once the imposing home of the March family - fascinating, manipulative isabelle, Charlie, her brutal and dangerous brother, and the wild and untamed twins, Emmeline and Adeline. But Angelfield House conceals a chilling secret whose impact still resonates.
Now Margaret Lea is investigating Angelfield's past - and the mystery of the March family starts to unravel. What has the house been hiding? What is its connection with the enigmatic author Vida Winter? And what is it in Margaret's own troubled past that causes her to fall so pwerfully under Angelfield's spell?
Review: I really liked the sound of this book from the Blurb on the back, but I found it very confusing and quite hard to read. The main character, Margaret, feels under developed, as do most of the characters in the story. It seems that the book should be twice the size to fit in all the details to flesh out the characters. The idea behind the story itself is very good, it just seems to lack depth.
The story begins when Margaret receives a letter from a prominent author who wants to meet her with a view to writing a biography. As the story developes it becomes clear that Vida Winter began life as a different person, and not a particularly nice one. There are a few twists and turns in the story but most of them are fairly predictable as is the ending. Although saying that, it is a satisfying ending.
The way the book is written is a bit irritating as it is not clear which period the story is set in and I kept trying to make Margaret a modern girl, but I dont think she is :dunno: I would have enjoyed it more had I been able to set Margaret in a time zone. I didn't really engage with the characters, they didn't come alive for me this time, which was a shame because overall the book is good. Its an interesting mystery story, with all the ingredients for a really good read, somehow tho (for me) it just didn't quite come off.
If you like mystery tales then give this one a look, but dont expect the characters to jump off the page and into your life - they dont.

Janet
15th December 2007, 14:48
I think your review was very good - and very useful for me because this was on my long-list for my next Bookworms choice but I will now dismiss it. Thanks. :)

chicken
15th December 2007, 15:02
Oh well now I feel bad, because you might have really liked it !

happyanddandy
15th December 2007, 15:53
thanks for that chicken - if you can't tell what era it is suppose to be set then there can't be a lot of depth to it!! :smile2:

chicken
15th December 2007, 16:34
Yes thats true happy, its quite unsettling to read a book like that, I dont know about you, but when I am reading a book it plays out in my head :blush: and with this one I couldn't put faces or costumes to any of the characters and I found that quite uncomfortable. Thing is I really wanted to love this book because the idea is so good, but ...........nope :roll:

justme
15th December 2007, 17:07
I just read a review of this on The Book Bag, after having looked it over at our local Borders and was thinking about getting it. I'm glad I've read your thoughts on the story...perhaps I'll leave this one off the tbr list for now.

happyanddandy
15th December 2007, 17:56
Mixed reviews on Librarything :smile2:

chicken
15th December 2007, 18:11
I have just had a look on The Book Bag and Library Thing, seems that they like it more than I did. Oh well each to their own, it wouldn't be as much fun if we were all the same :mrgreen:

Janet
15th December 2007, 20:06
Oh well now I feel bad, because you might have really liked it !
Sorry - I didn't mean to make you feel bad!

chicken
15th December 2007, 20:09
Dont think I will do another book review - its too much responsibility :lol:

Janet
15th December 2007, 20:23
:( Please don't let it stop you - I thought your review was great.

chicken
15th December 2007, 20:31
Thanks Janet. Thing is my opinion might have put you off reading a book that you may have loved, even tho I didn't get on with it, thus I feel bad :lol: Shame about the book tho it had the potential to be a fab book, but wasn't really :roll:

Janet
15th December 2007, 20:43
Thanks Janet. Thing is my opinion might have put you off reading a book that you may have loved, even tho I didn't get on with it, thus I feel bad :lol: Shame about the book tho it had the potential to be a fab book, but wasn't really :roll:
As I have 50+ on my to read pile, and I'm definitely likely to buy more before I've read them, I'm not worried about missing one book that I may have enjoyed - honestly! :)

chicken
15th December 2007, 20:47
Right then, if you put it like that.............:lol: 50!........really - You lucky thing ;) I have about 3 that I have not read in the house. Been mulling over Terry Pratchett - might have a look at those, but there are so many :roll:

madcow
15th December 2007, 21:26
I bought this on a whim a few weeks back, the blurb on the back sounded interesting. I will read it eventually just can't say when lol.

chicken
15th December 2007, 21:41
Hi Madcow - I would be interested to hear your views on the book ....... let me know what you think

madcow
15th December 2007, 21:43
No problem chicken.

happyanddandy
15th December 2007, 22:16
Chicken - your review would not put me off reading it! :smile2:

chicken
15th December 2007, 22:23
Oh thats good ! want to borrow it ????? :mrgreen:

happyanddandy
15th December 2007, 22:50
Oh thats good ! want to borrow it ????? :mrgreen:


hmmm... maybe in a coupla years :lol: :lol:

chicken
15th December 2007, 22:58
:lol: dont blame ya :lol:

Deirdre
16th December 2007, 11:29
I have read this book in the earlier this year and eventhough I enjoyed it I share the view of Chicken. I do believe the character of Margaret and some others were underdeveloped and I too had trouble with the timesetting. Margaret is not a modern girl, I placed her somewhere in the Fifties or Sixties but could be totally wrong.

frankie
8th August 2008, 20:44
Are we talking about Diane Setterfield's The Thirteenth Tale? Because if we are, I couldn't be more confused. Never before have I heard of a person who didn't like that book :icon_eek: And this is the second thread on disliking The Thirteenth Tale that I've come across on this forum! Or was the Finnish translation just so good that it made a poor read fantastic? :lol: That would be a first...

Seriously speaking, I liked most of the characters and I really enjoyed the storyline and was surprised at the twist in the end. It was one of those books that you want to read in one sitting.

If there's anyone on the fence with this book, go ahead and give the book one try, there's no harm done. :)

Ruth
8th August 2008, 23:18
I enjoyed this very much. I remember trying to work out when it was set, as there is no actual references in the book with regard to the era.

LucyD
10th August 2008, 14:33
I started reading this book last night - am hooked after only a few chapters. So atmospheric and intriguing!

LucyD
15th August 2008, 10:31
I finished reading this last night and really enjoyed it! Am I the only one?! I thought it was great, a real page-turner. I did guess a few of the twists, admittedly and could have done without quite so much about Margaret's twin but overall, I thought it was fab. Beautifully written and really original.
I didn't mind not knowing exactly when it was set - I felt it was a timeless sort of book which didn't need pinning to a specific year. Margaret did feel slightly old-fashioned, I thought, so wouldn't have pegged her as 21st century, and there was no mention of anything remotely 'modern' like mobile phones etc, but I was happy to go along not knowing the date.
:)

Kylie
15th August 2008, 10:35
I enjoyed it too, Lucy. I posted my review on my reading blog here a couple of days ago, and I felt the same way as you about those points you made :smile2:

Ruth
15th August 2008, 10:59
I really enjoyed it too. I didn't mind not knowing when it was set either. I felt it perhaps added an element of intrigue.

Smint
16th August 2008, 09:48
I enjoyed it too, although I found it a little unsettling not to know when it was set - and some of the characters annoyed me - but I think they were supposed to :D