PDA

View Full Version : David Mitchell - Black Swan Green


Freewheeling Andy
5th July 2006, 22:47
Well, somewhere else on this site I called David Mitchell as the person writing the greatest literature in Britain at the moment. I'm sure that in a few years time my tastes will move on, but I've not read anything from Britain recently that comes close to Cloud Atlas, except, perhaps, his latest novel Black Swan Green.

It's not a book about the Japanese Yakuza, it's not an exotic babushka travelling through time from the 18th to 25th centuries.

It's a departure, to a suppsedly gentler age and place, and a gentler narrative form comes with it.

The only structural excitment comes in the form of 13 self contained story-chapters, each from one of 13 months in the life of a 13 year old boy (well, he's 13 for most of it, although clearly with 13 months he must age at least once).

Rural Worcestershire in 1982 may be the setting, and the stories may be those of an adolescent, but the themes are more universal, and this is one of those aspects that makes it a great book. The stories of being bullies, of desperation for acceptance, of outsiderhood, may seem simple, but they tell tales of the kindness of those you don't expect kindness from; they tell of guilt, of redemption. It's almost a moral novel, in the way it takes up the theme of the importance of being true to yourself, but that would make it sound trite.

It's not trite. It's wonderful. It's got a light, light touch in the writing, is beautifully easy to read, has humour lacing every page, even when darker subjects are around.

Mitchell has, like he apparently always does, moved one or two characters from previous books into this one. Robert Frobisher and Vivian Ayrs return in passing from Cloud Atlas, for example. That adds a little to the fun of the book, but it doesn't need much adding. There's so much going on.

I would struggle to recommend it high enough. Lovely, brilliant, magnificent.

Kell
6th July 2006, 06:10
This sounds rather interesting - I may add it to my own to-read list later on in the year...

Renniemist
30th November 2006, 19:56
I absolutely loved this book. Jason’s misfortunes seemed very real indeed. I liked the fact it was set in 1982. I liked the appearance of the character from Cloud Atlas. That was such a good touch for those who have read that book, but would not have affected the story for those that have not.

I felt sorry when the book came to and end, and I had a feeling that nothing was going to be as good again. I have read many good books this year but that is the only one I can say that about.

I will most certainly be reading more books by David Mitchell.

Janet
30th November 2006, 21:48
I really like the sound of this. My friend read it earlier this year and said it was good. I'm waiting for the paperback though, which I think must be out soonish!

Renniemist
30th November 2006, 22:04
My copy is from the library and unfortunately I will have to go back soon. I might get it for myself when it comes out in paperback. I could read it again.

TammyRich
30th November 2006, 23:25
I have asked for this from my hubby for Christmas. I really hope he gets it for me. If not I'm off to the library. I loved Cloud Atlas. I would say it was the best book I read this year.

Hubby grew up in rural Worcestershire and would have been may be a year or two older than Jason. I think I would have been a bit younger and know the area having visited mother-in-law there. But I read an excerpt in a Saturday newspaper and it read brilliantly and I am sure I will enjoy it. Unfortunatly OH doesn't read novels or fiction so he won't appreciate it.

Freewheeling Andy
1st December 2006, 15:35
Ah. I'm really glad you enjoyed it, Rennie. Some people I know felt it was a bit flat because it wasn't the same as Cloud Atlas and Ghostwritten, it wasn't so expansive and crazily ambitious. But they're wrong.

Renniemist
1st December 2006, 16:22
I have not read Ghostwritten yet, but I think I liked Black Swan Green even better than Cloud Atlas. It certainly was very different from Cloud Atlas and I think this shows that David Mitchell can write well about many things.

happyanddandy
5th August 2007, 18:27
I loved this book! Written from a 12 year old boy perspective it comes alive. Mitchell's descriptions are spot on. For example when he likens bus diesel fumes to a newly sharpened pencil smell it is exactly what a schoolboy would use as a referenc point. I particularly liked how the author dealt with Jason's stammering via the 'Hangman' squeezing his throat so that he could not get his words out. The bullying made me feel quite emotional too. Do read this if you can. Literature of the best kind.

For me the references to the Falklands war, Maggie Thatcher and the music of the early 80s provided added value. Definitely the best I have read this year so far. :smile2:

JudyB
5th August 2007, 23:03
Know what you mean HandD - I enjoyed the nostalgia element too. If you like that sort of thing you might enjoy The Rotter's Club - again teenage boy perspective, beautifully written, with 70's politics/news events thrown in - quite moving in places but also funny.