PDA

View Full Version : Alexander McCall Smith - 44 Scotland Street


Kell
28th May 2006, 21:11
44 Scotland Street
Author: Alexander McCall Smith
ISBN # 0349118973
Publisher: Abacus
1st Published: 2005
326 pages

Welcome to 44 Scotland Street, home to some of Edinburgh's most colorful characters. There's Pat, a twenty-year-old who has recently moved into a flat with Bruce, an athletic young man with a keen awareness of his own appearance. Their neighbor, Domenica, is an eccentric and insightful widow. In the flat below are Irene and her appealing son Bertie, who is the victim of his mother’s desire for him to learn the saxophone and Italian–all at the tender age of five. Love triangles, a lost painting, intriguing new friends, and an encounter with a famous Scottish crime writer are just a few of the ingredients that add to this delightful and witty portrait of Edinburgh society.

This was first published as a serial in The Scotsman newspaper and, as a result, the chapters are quite short and self-contained within the big picture, making this an excellent choice for readers who can only snatch a few moments in their day for relaxing with a book. It has highs and lows and sometimes the overall plot appears to get a little lost as different characters, each with their own stories, wander across the pages, drawing us into their lives as we visit them all in turn, occasionally interacting with each other without realizing the drama they add to each other’s tales. It’s humorous, witty and fun – an interesting experiment in serialized writing that has paid off.

Rating: 6

This book is on my Sale or Swap list

Inver
21st July 2006, 11:28
I have just finished reading this and have to say I skimmed a lot of it. Although knowing parts of Edinburgh did find it quite amusing. Loved the chapter when they end up in the charitiy shop in Morningside...could just imagine where they were. Also I actually worked in the Braid Hills Hotel as a receptionist way back too. :mrgreen:

magdadh
6th September 2006, 09:44
I found it rather sweet but totally forgetable apart from the genral mood. Which is probably what the author intended anyway...

Danna
29th June 2007, 21:25
I enjoyed both of the books in the series... but, I have to admit that I listened to the unabridged versions. The narrator brought each of the characters to life, and I couldn't get enough!

Danna

JudyB
29th June 2007, 21:30
I've read an enjoyed these - I think they have a feel of The Tales of the City series which was also written originally in serial form - although TTotC are darker.

happyanddandy
30th June 2007, 13:52
I read and thoroughly enjoyed this about 2-3 years ago - I have the follow up waiting in my TBR list :smile2:

Danna
9th July 2007, 20:33
Judy,

I had never heard about The Tales of the City (not to be confused with the Two Cities!) until you posted the above letter. I just looked at Amazon, and see that it actually is a series of books. (I should have known that as "library lady," you would know!) Since both of us like the 44 Scotland Street happenings so much, I am thinking that I would probably like the Tales of the City series, also.

Thanks for posting about them...

JudyB
9th July 2007, 20:41
Judy,

I had never heard about The Tales of the City (not to be confused with the Two Cities!) until you posted the above letter. I just looked at Amazon, and see that it actually is a series of books. (I should have known that as "library lady," you would know!) Since both of us like the 44 Scotland Street happenings so much, I am thinking that I would probably like the Tales of the City series, also.

Thanks for posting about them...


I started reading the series during the 90's - think I finished one and two and got part way through number 3. They are not as innocent as The Scotland Street series but I think they had a similiar atmosphere plus they too started life as a daily story in a newspaper. It would be nice to continue with them sometime especially as Armistead Maupin has recently written a novel about one of the main characters.

Danna
13th July 2007, 14:01
Judy...

You probably think I'm following you from one Alexander McCall Smith thread to the next!

Now you have piqued my interest in Armistead Maupin's Tales of the City. (Would the Tale's book character you are referring to happen to be Michael Tolliver?) I'm off to order the first Tales of the City... your taste for Alexander McCall Smith suggests that I might just enjoy Maupin!

Louiseog
13th July 2007, 14:24
I enjoyed the Tales of the City books, more than McCall Smith actually, have just read his most recent, Michael Tolliver Lives which I enjoyed.

JudyB
13th July 2007, 18:41
Danna - hope you do enjoy them

Louise - hmm think my wishlist/tbr has just got longer again! I feel like I'm going to have to read The Tales of the City series again first to re-acquaint myself with the characters.

Louiseog
13th July 2007, 18:44
Danna - hope you do enjoy them

Louise - hmm think my wishlist/tbr has just got longer again! I feel like I'm going to have to read The Tales of the City series again first to re-acquaint myself with the characters.
I was quite surprised as I read them about 20 years ago and I remembered them! Mouse and Mrs Madrigal wow!

Danna
15th July 2007, 18:21
I just ordered the first of the Tales of the City books. I can't wait to get them.

Thanks (to all) for the recommendation. I am always on the look-out for a new author!