Jump to content
  • Announcements

    • Michelle

      Important Announcement!   07/28/2018

      Dear BCF members,   This forum has been running now for many years, and over that time we have seen many changes. Generalised forums are nowhere near as popular as they once were, and they have been very much taken over by blogs, vlogs and social media discussions. Running a forum well takes money, and a lot of care and attention, as there is so much which goes on behind the scenes to keep things running smoothly.   With all of this in mind, and after discussion within the current moderator team, the decision has been made to close this forum in its current format. I know that this will disappoint a lot of our long term members, but I want to reassure you that it's not a decision which has been taken lightly.    The remaining moderator team have agreed that we do not want to lose everything which is special about our home, and so we are starting a brand new facebook group, so that people can stay in touch, and discussions can continue. We can use it for free and should be easier for us to run (it won't need to be updated or hosted). We know not everyone has FaceBook, but we hope that those of you who are interested will join the group. We will share the link, and send invites as soon as we are ready to go. Added: We may as well get this going, find us here: https://www.facebook.com/groups/195289821332924/   The forum will close to new registrations, but will remain open for some time, to allow people to collect up any information, reading lists etc they need to, and to ensure they have contact details for those they wish to stay in touch with.    The whole team feel sad to say goodbye, but we also feel that it's perhaps time and that it feels like the right choice. We hope we can stay in touch with all of you through our new FaceBook group.   I personally want to thank everyone who has helped me moderate the forum, both in the past and the present, and I also want to thank every single person who has visited, and shared their love of books.. I'm so proud of everything we've achieved, and the home we built.   Please visit the new section in the Lounge section to discuss this further, ask questions etc.
willoyd

Wolf Hall by Hilary Mantel

Recommended Posts

I won't read your linked post yet as I intend to read this eventually, but I'm glad to hear you liked it. :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I try to avoid saying anything in a review that will spoil it for anybody else. Primarily comments about style.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was intrigued when I first heard about this book, and I enjoyed reading your review willoyd, so this is definitely on my wish list. :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just started this one and from your review and all I've read and can't wait until tonight (I shall have a little time to devote ot it) Yeahhhh.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've seen this book around but never picked it up (the cover art intrigued me :D) Thanks for the review. I'm engrossed by the Tudor period so this is firmly on my wishlist :blush:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I started reading the book a few days ago. So far it is great. I find myself re-reading passages to better understand the descriptions, conversations or actions. I am looking forward to continue reading (can read for short period of times).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Definitely one I fancy... I have a great interest in the Tudor period and read a mix of historical fiction and fact...it's interesting to compare how various authors interpret primary and secondary sources.

 

It was on my list and because of this review it has reached the top!

 

LITT

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am currently reading this book and it is one of the best books I have read in a long time. One of the best things about it and what Mantel is undoubtedly gifted in is she takes what could have been a quite boring subject and weaves a detailed and intriguing back story for Cromwell.

Most of it must be imagined and embroidered by her such as the dialogue and the descriptions but she makes it so believable that she has me hooked. Cromwell appeared to me a boring character from the Tudor period being I thought either a politician or a churchman unlike Anne Boleyn or Henry VIII or Elizabeth I etc but I am now fascinated.

 

6/10 is way too low. Can't think what else this person reads to give it a 6/10. They have obviously never read any really bad books.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6/10 is way too low. Can't think what else this person reads to give it a 6/10. They have obviously never read any really bad books.

A friend of mine recently tried to read Wolf Hall and gave up after 90 pages. On talking to him about it he echoed almost exactly what the review above says.

 

Unperturbed, I dived into it a couple of days ago and am currently about 320 pages in - and I think it's utterly brilliant. I feared the worst after my friend gave his views but nothing could be further from the truth. Perhaps there is an element of reverse psychology going on. I certainly wish he'd given it more of a chance but, in the end, it just comes down to differing tastes. I think Mantel's writing style flows wonderfully, and it's carried me along to the point where only the need for sleep has stopped me from reading all night. The 'he' business mentioned in the review has not really jumped out at me at all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have just finished Wolf Hall, and I loved it! I hope there is a follow up soon as it is one of my best reads this year! On finishing the book, I just wanted to know what happened to Thomas Cromwell next!

 

However I have to agree with the use of 'He' as detailed in Readwine's review.

I noticed it early on, and decided if I just stick to the rule 'the 'He' in question is always Thomas Cromwell' I was able to filter it out, and enjoy the novel. I then noticed that later in the book Mantel started to say 'He, Cromwell,...' instead.

 

 

However this did not spoil my enjoyment of the book, and I also think 6/10 is way too low!

 

So I'm giving Wolf Hall 9/10!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

After starting this book in February and after picking it up...putting it down several times I finally finished it last night. Incredible book. Yes it felt like a mammoth task to pick it up each time but as soon as I did I was there. Normally, I tend to skim the odd bits of books, but with this one I felt I had to read every single word properly as it was so intricate and you could so easily lose some brilliant nuances.

 

I'm looking forward to the sequel although with some trepidation because I know that bit of history...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had picked this book up to buy several times and put it back each time. But having read what everybody has to say, I think next time I see it I am going to have to buy it! :(

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I loved this book. I also want a sequel because I know that Thomas Cromwell was executed for various reasons and I've read that King Henry VIII later expressed regret for the execution of someone he considered a true friend. The writing style I found confusing at times too and had to re-read many pages and paragraphs. The bibliography of characters at the start of the book is a must, I would have been lost without it ..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Very interesting to read people's thoughts on this book. I have been reading it for about a week and I agree that the writing style appears to be confusing, but somehow the meaning seems to come through. It does need very careful reading, but the character list is an invaluable help. Its not my style or type of book at all but its really intriguing me and I can't put it down. I would definitely recommend giving it a try.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I read this earlier in the year and loved it. I found the writing style to be a bit of a hurdle but only because I wanted to speed through the book and get to the end. I forced myself to slow down and absorb the book properly.

 

I can't wait for the sequel!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree that the writing style left it somewhat confusing in places. At the beginning it did get in the way of the story for me, left me constantly re-reading bits and getting frustrated. However, I did overcome it mostly once I assumed he meant cromwell.

Good story, has left me wanting to know more about the history of the monarchy. I would have rated it 8/10 but the awkward writing style has lost it an extra point. 7/10

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am in two minds about it because I had have it is a bit of a struggle but I have enjoyed the other Hilary Mantel books I have read, so you never can tell, if I see it in Tescos, I will pick up a copy :)

Edited by Weave

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A friend of mine recently tried to read Wolf Hall and gave up after 90 pages. On talking to him about it he echoed almost exactly what the review above says.

 

Unperturbed, I dived into it a couple of days ago and am currently about 320 pages in - and I think it's utterly brilliant. I feared the worst after my friend gave his views but nothing could be further from the truth. Perhaps there is an element of reverse psychology going on. I certainly wish he'd given it more of a chance but, in the end, it just comes down to differing tastes. I think Mantel's writing style flows wonderfully, and it's carried me along to the point where only the need for sleep has stopped me from reading all night. The 'he' business mentioned in the review has not really jumped out at me at all.

 

I agree. I started this with some trepidation about the style (present tense, confusing use of he) but so far about 100 pages in I'm really enjoying it. I had been interested in this book since it was first published, but had been put off by the comments about the writing style. Only bought it as it was on offer at Waterstones before Christmas.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I loved this book; one of the best historical novels I have read. I studied the Tudors many years ago and this made it them come alive. The only problem with the sequel will be that I know the ending!!! But I suppose the fun is in the getting there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now

×