Jump to content

P. D. James


Recommended Posts

I noticed that there was no thread on P. D James.

 

I don't know what others feel, but for me she is the best living crime writer. I know she may be considered old fashioned in that she writes the closed group whodunnits, but I love her writing and I love trying to work out who the murderer is. I also enjoy the environments she sets her novels in. Even the cliches like the armchairs on either side of the open fire.

 

Best ones?

 

Well Death in Holy Orders is up there. Devices & Desires was very good & I also enjoyed The Children of Men. I must watch the film!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have read most of PD James books, the Adam Dalgleish ones and Cordelia Grey ones. I have read some more than once - I really enjoyed them. I haven't read the later ones. I loved the character of Adam Dalgleish, a thoughtful poet as well as a detective. It's a very long time since I picked up PDJ - must add to TBR :thud:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you haven't read Death in Holy Orders, you should pick that one up. I think it's one of her best.

 

P.D. James is a wonderful writer. I love her Adam Dalgleish novels. I enjoyed her last one 'The Light House' but agree with you that 'Death in Holy Orders' is one of her best:)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I love P.D. James as well. She is certainly one of our more talented female crime writers. Death in Holy Orders was brilliant. The Lighthouse was also enjoyable

 

Martin Shaw is absolutely delectable as Adam Dalgleish and makes the drama even more enjoyable to watch :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

I must disagree. I tried reading The Murder Room, but for me there's something wrong if I'm on the page 130 in a detective story and noone has died yet! In a word: boring. I was thinking "come on! Kill someone already!" which of course made me feel absolutely terrible, eventhough I was only thinking of a book. I don't know, maybe I've just gotten too used to the Agatha Christie's.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh, okay, so maybe I should have started with something else. Thank you, for telling me.

 

I guess I just approach it from the different angle. I like to first have the body (gosh, this sounds so horrible!) and then start digging around, figuring out the people and events leading to the crime. If you continue on that thought, I don't want to get to know the people first, then suddenly, once I've started to have opinions about them and maybe like them, someone ends up dead. And more over, someone of those people I already know is the killer! After all, I get invelved emotionally, I still cry during Lion King.

 

From a totally unbiased point of view, it's nice to see stories, that are fundamentally detective stories, to be more than these single layered whodunnit-mysteries. But I still don't wish for my newfound friends to turn out to be murderers.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

But I still don't wish for my newfound friends to turn out to be murderers.

 

But it's the same with Agatha Christie novels, though. It's nearly always a likable character that ends up being the villain.

 

Try Death in Holy Orders or Devices & Desires. I can't remember the page numbers of the first murders, but I was a little disappointed with The Murder Room. It was far from her best.

 

Do bear in mind that for the followers of the Dalgleish books, there is also the ongoing affair with (name escapes me) which is now into the third book & will he won't he marry her (or even get past "first base"). Anyway, my point is that P. D. James is a crime writer, but her books are about more than just crime.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh, that is true. It's never the shadiest of characters. But still, you've only barely gotten the names straight, when someone dies, so as you get to know them you have that nagging voice at the back of your head going "it could be them".

 

I will. Boy, was everyone right about the new additions to the TBR list. Just few days and.. wow. You all are good! Anyways, I'll let you know once I get on with either one of those books. I am willing to give her another try.

 

You know what, I think that's part of what bothered me because I wan't expecting that. So all the extra drama he had going on seemed like an intrusion to that traditional style of detective stories. Had someone told me beforehand about that, I might have taken a more positive attitute towards it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In all the detective stories I read I very rarely get the murderer right. I'd make a lousy detective.

 

I agree that Devices and Desires and Death in Holy Orders are probably the best, and that Murder Room was not quite up there perhaps with some of the others. Certain Justice was about the same level perhaps as Murder Room. I feel she has gotten better over time though, whereas a lot of writers are the other way around. Starting writing rubbish toward the end of their careers.

 

But she is excellent, and as someone said, there is so much more that just the detective story. I love the Adam Dalgliesh books where he is down in Norfolk, motoring through the countryside, and reminiscing about his younger days in that area.

 

I saw PD James many years ago, before she was a really big deal, in a bookshop meet and greet type thing. She was really nice.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 years later...

I find some books were really hard going and I just could not get into them, then others a really great. Devices and Desires was heavy going but really good I was glad I stuck it out.

 

Death in Holy Orders was blooming terrible It really put me off of her books for a long time.

 

Her recent books were better Just a lottery I suppose and up to individual taste too

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 months later...
  • 2 months later...
  • 2 years later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...