Just thought I'd come and add my two-pence here.... I read Twilight and New Moon a while ago, when they first came out. At the risk of getting eaten by fangirls, I have to say I can't really see what all the fuss is about.
They're not awfully written, but nor are they literary masterpieces. I really wasn't moved to get the third one when it came out. Bella is a 'Mary-Sue' and Edward....vampires should not sparkle. It's not right I guess the werewolves were sort of cool but, then again, lots of people do werewolves.
I think to write of the age old battle between the lycanthropes and the vampires, and write it well, one needs an original take on it. While there were some inventive bits in Twilight, like the sparkling (as odd as it was) to me it just felt like an average vamp vs. werewolf book of no particular speciality.
What makes the books attractive besides hot guys and an angsty love triangle? (To you, I mean. I dislike angsty romance.)
Feel free to throw things at me now. Just nothing too sharp or that will stain, please.