Oh dear, I didn't think of the spoiler thing! ooops, is there any way I can edit it?! Sorry!
I think you make a valid point regarding WH. I think the reason why I prefer Jane Eyre is simply because I loved and cared for the characters. In WH, I found it a struggle to actually like any of the characters, in fact, I found them so annoying! I did however think Heathcliff had so many layers to him and he was an enjoyable enigma.